Genre

Fantasy, Dark Psychological Fairy-tale

Audience

18 & Up

Author’s Worldview

Catholic

Year Published

2022

Themes

feminism, sexuality, violence, freedom, redemption

 

Reviewed by

Courtney Guest Kim

The Devil always begins by giving thee work that is just. Then he tells thee, thou dost just work, therefore thou art just. And then he tells thee, thou are just, and therefore any work thou dost is just.

            Lady Isabel and The Elf Knight reads as though one of the darker Grimm’s Fairy Tales has been turned into a novel, with the moral that personal freedom cannot be achieved through violence, even if you are female.  Lady Isabel is an anti-heroine who follows the well-worn path of rejecting the responsibilities she has inherited while taking her privileges for granted. But in this story her choices are not celebrated as a bid for freedom. Instead, the focus is on the selfishness with which she pursues the thrills of irresponsibility and enjoys the rush of power that violence can bring. Very soon she begins to experience the terrible consequences, which at first merely destroy other people’s lives. Eventually, however, she finds that the price of violence is her own miserable isolation.

Lady Isabel runs off with the Elf Knight, but what she does with him breaks from the pattern of her victimized predecessors. She chooses a path of vengeance that at first seems legitimate but which soon escapes her control. Slowly she awakens to a sense of concern for the real effects of her actions and becomes willing to sacrifice herself on behalf of others. Redemption for her involves a hard, tragic path. The counter-feminist challenge of this moral fable involves serious grappling with the dilemmas of postmodern womanhood, with a clear-eyed examination of various dead-ends, including the dead-end of nostalgia for an imaginary age of innocence. It works as a story because of the stark fairy tale structure. As in a fairy tale, Isabel experiences a series of stylized encounters, but as in a novel, the interiority of the characters is the focus. The result is a dark but fascinating psycho-fable.

Lady Isabel sinks into a spiritual morass, which at the level of the fairy tale is the result of an enchantment. As with all enchantments, she cannot free herself but must find the right source of help. At the novelistic level, her struggle brings up issues of female sexuality and feminine gender roles, as well as character transformation through suffering. There are also Biblical echoes in her story of the demon-possessed bride from the book of Tobit who cannot help but murder a series of seven husbands on seven failed wedding nights. But in this story, there is no angel to rescue her, and the various attempts to break the enchantment result in failure, until, in true fairy tale fashion, a pure soul comes along from an unexpected direction. Lady Isabel’s story is a cautionary tale as far as sex is concerned, with the sort of characters one expects from a Young Adult fantasy. But the complex themes and frank discussion of sexual topics, while not at all erotic put it into the New Adult category.

At no point does the plot collapse into easy solutions, and the story kept me guessing till the final scene, which ties off both the fairy tale and the novelistic elements with an intriguing flourish. General readers of fantasy may find this story too allegorical, and there is no completely compelling character with which to sympathize. This is a morality tale that will appeal to readers who are sympathetic to the questioning of feminist ideology and to honest probing of what it means for a woman to be good.

Saint Michael: Above the 38th Parallel by Shanti Guy

The true story of St. Michael, the original punch-communism-in-the-face superhero

Mark’s Noble Quest by Katherine Campbell

Can a twenty-first century guy survive an Arthurian quest—and keep his true love?

Books for Lent

Deepen your Lenten reflection with these stories of repentance and forgiveness

Our Lady of the Artilects by Andrew Gillsmith

Robots, Souls, Muslim & Catholic Friendships, and the sacramental reality that binds them all together.

Vigil by Russell Newquist

“Big Trouble in Little China” meets Saint George and the Dragon

How the Dragon Awards Could Uplift Catholic Fiction

If you don’t like current state of mainstream publishing and wish there were more widely available alternatives, this is your chance to help make that a reality.

Somewhither by John C. Wright An Unwhithering Realm

What if the Multi-verse were not a theory to disprove God? What if he created it, and all humanity must unite to fight the powers of Babel?

Infernal Affairs by Declan Finn

St. Tommy finally comes face-to-face with the warlock that has been behind the events of the previous two books while fighting off hordes of everything from gangsters to vampires.

Comet Dust by C.D. Verhoff

A Catholic end-of days inspired by the private revelations of the saints.

Bonvida’s Awakening, by C.D. Smith

Can Atticus live up to the legacy of his birthright? An adventure fantasy novel for teens about good and evil, friendship, and identity.

A Changing of the Guard; Three Last Things Book 2 by Corinna Turner

A priest to Death Row inmates, Fr. Jacob must face the earthly consequences of ‘love thy enemy’

Crusader St. Tommy NYPD Book 5 By: Declan Finn

Detective Nolan embarks on a Crusade against demonic sex traffickers trying to raise a demon.

Wake of Malice by Eleanor Bourg Nicholson

Sent to investigate a series of murders in the Irish countryside, Hugh soon finds signs that someone is messing with old Celtic myths best left undisturbed.

Most Highly Favored Daughter by Janice Palko

Her perfect life hides her city’s darkest secrets. Can Cara face the light of truth and come to understand real love?

Brother Wolf by Eleanor Bourg Nicholson

Swept into a werewolf hunt with two nuns, a dashing guardian and a jolly priest, Athene Howard applies her intellectual skills to unravel this mysterious new Papist world.

Siren Spell by Karina Fabian

Immortal dragon Vern can handle anything—until a curse turns him human…

Cinderella by Charles Perrault

The true story of the Catholic saint who inspired the myth of Cinderella

Elfling by Corinna Turner

Serapia Ravena is on a mission to find and keep her father, but he has transgressed a boundary that no creature has the right to cross. Only the mercy of God can resolve this tension.

Three Last Things or The Hounding of Carl Jarrold, Soulless Assassin by Corinna Turner

The last day of a convicted murderer’s life: Can he save his soul in time?

Trapped in Time by Jerry J. Weis

Can a team of misfit teens save the day in this wholesome time-traveling romp?