Genre

Nonfiction

Audience

15 & Up

Author’s Worldview

Catholic

Year Published

2019

Themes

literary analysis, the Eucharist, Christ figures, literary allusions, intertextuality, the hero’s journey

 

Reviewed by

Dr. Lisa Theus

Even a casual audience member of Lord of the Rings – books or movies – is struck by the depth of the lore. It’s not an overstatement to say that Tolkien’s fantasy world is fully fleshed out and genre-defining. But not everyone knows about Tolkien’s strong Catholic faith and how those influences show up in Middle Earth. If you’re a Tolkien fan and a Catholic, Scott L. Smith, Jr. has written an approachable book for you. Lord of the Rings & the Eucharist is a brief volume exploring the similarities between Middle Earth and Catholicism. Containing discussion of the movies, books, and extended legendarium, this collection of essays is informative, thought-provoking, and well-researched.

Topics include understanding the Eucharist, the Garden of Eden, Kingship, Ents, and more. It bridges events from the Trees of early Middle Earth history to Frodo’s need for lembas waybread, the Tolkien parallel to the Eucharist. There’s also an assortment of artwork throughout the book taken from the movies and editions of the novels—and the art of Middle Earth is always breathtaking.  Smith also includes a bonus chapter on Star Wars. On the one hand, it feels out of place, but on the other hand, it has the most important discussion in this book about why Catholicism parallels so well with these popular works of literature. The heroic story structure that both Luke and Frodo follow are based on ancient myths, which in a sense primed humanity for the life of Christ.

It’s an understatement to say that Tolkien’s Middle Earth lore is dense. Smith doesn’t expect the reader to know everything. He tries to keep it straightforward enough that even if you only know the movies and the basic story of “Frodo must destroy ring,” you’ll be able to follow the analysis. I’ll admit, however, that trying to keep the names straight can still be a challenge. I read the Silmarillion some years ago, and I really had to focus to remember the names and connections from time to time. The best audience would be Catholic fans who want to delve deeper into the lore, but haven’t had a chance to and are looking for an approachable text to get started. Although the book has sources and endnotes, the writing is far from academic.

Curious Protestant and Secular fans of Lord of the Rings will still be engaged if they’re interested in literary analysis. Secular readers might be critical of the interpretation that this is the only or even the best way to read Tolkien, but the book still provides useful talking points.

While I—like other fans—may object to Tolkien and allegory being written in the same sentence, it’s worth it to set aside that bias and take the work on its own terms: the connections that one reader makes between Christianity and Lord of the Rings. Tolkien himself even allowed that stories and allegories converge in Truth, as Smith quotes in his chapter discussing this issue. You’ll find many parallels that add richness to the influences Tolkien undoubtedly drew upon to form his genre-defining world. And you may be convinced that the many points Smith raises build a case for seeing the lore of Middle Earth as an entire Biblical and Catholic allegory.

The conversation about religious influences in Lord of the Rings is still ongoing, but this book has enough gems for all levels of nerds to get something out of it.

Shadowmancer by G.P. Taylor

A dark fantasy along the lines of Revelation itself.

Theology In the Bottle: Where Cana Meets the Cross By A. P. Schreck

Prayerful meditations to pair with your journal and a glass of wine.

Love, Treachery, and Other Terrors by Katharine Campbell

This quirky, fairytale fantasy is a fun and amusing read with a serious moral backbone.

On Heaven’s Doorstep by Andrea Jo Rodgers

When you’re on the front lines of life and death, it’s hard to avoid seeing real miracles.

Zeal & Zest: Where to Begin with Hillaire Belloc

Belloc was known as a Catholic polemicist with a vicious talent for skewering his opponents. Anyone struggling to persevere as a Christian in the fields of journalism or media should read him. His children’s books have an acerbic humor that will appeal to bored veterans of political correctness, especially teens.

How the Dragon Awards Could Uplift Catholic Fiction

If you don’t like current state of mainstream publishing and wish there were more widely available alternatives, this is your chance to help make that a reality.

Why Reading Fiction Made Me a Better Catholic

How reading fiction became a crucial step in my conversion to the Catholic Church.

Crusader St. Tommy NYPD Book 5 By: Declan Finn

Detective Nolan embarks on a Crusade against demonic sex traffickers trying to raise a demon.

Revelation by Flannery O’Connor

Flannery O’Connor takes us into the mental experience of one of those people Jesus condemned.

Jennifer the Damned By Karen Ullo

A story of a teenage vampire without the glamorous tempting allure, trying to really live in the real world.

How Can You Still Be Catholic? By Christopher Sparks

There are many good apologetics books out there but this book teaches you how to speak to the heart as much as the head.

Heavenly Rescues and Answered Prayers: True Stories of Faith and Miracles from a First Responder by Andrew Jo Rodgers

A book that’s great to have on hand when one needs a reminder that there are good people out there and that God’s hand is in everything.

Silence by Shusaku Endo

The story that introduced faith to one of the most secular nations on Earth

Do Not Be Afraid: A Review of Shane Leslie’s Ghost Book

A real-life paranormal investigation in light of Church teaching and tradition

Unconditional Surrender By Evelyn Waugh

We should not invite evil as a means to display our courage.

Secrets of Successful Financial Planning by Dan Gallagher

“Where the heart is, there will your treasure be.” Uncover what is most important to you regarding your money.

At Heaven’s Edge:  True Stories of Faith and Rescue By Andrea Jo Rodgers

As an EMT Rodgers has seen God work in ways that defy medical analysis.

The Exorcist by William Peter Blatty

I knew this book was going to be scary. What I did NOT expect was to be left with a deep feeling of peace and comfort.

Unrepeatable: Cultivating the Unique Calling of Every Person By Luke Burgis and Joshua Miller, PhD

Every person is gifted with a primary vocation from birth based on motivational patterns.