Genre

Romance

Audience

Highschool & Up

Author’s Worldview

Catholic

Year Published

2019

Themes

love, pornography, child pornography, slice of life, widow, widowhood, single-mother, single-motherhood, motherhood, fatherhood, theology of the body, grief, illness, stalking, stalker, bachelor, chastity, perseverance, patience, waiting for marriage

 

Reviewed by

A.R.K. Watson

If you are looking for a romance that breaks all the usual and dysfunctional tropes the genre is known for, Astfalk has already established herself as one of the most reliable and prolific authors this organization has yet seen.

This latest novel opens with a sweet encounter between Brian, a middle-aged bachelor who has given up on dating, and Melanie, a recent widow and single mother of three. Brian tells God that if He wants him to marry, He’ll have to drop the woman into his lap. You can guess what kind of meet-cute that leads to (a ‘Meet-Cute’ is the term for the scene in a romance story when the fated couple meets and it’s usually much more interesting than in real life). Yet as refreshingly decent as our couple is, the world is anything but. It would be hard enough to fall in love when the guy worries that his old pornography habit will overpower him again, and the girl is still mourning a husband while struggling to raise three children. Just when it looks like maturity and good communication will see them through, Brian starts showing signs of a latent disease and Melanie begins to get calls from her children’s school that a stranger has been stalking her five-year-old son.

All in Good Time is a story about a romance that perseveres through trial and surprise. It paints a beautiful picture of love that is both exciting and steady. Young or old, married or unmarried, any romance fan will find Brian and Melanie’s story one of hope and encouragement.

The idyllic couple and dates at butterfly gardens had me expecting a typically light and fluffy tale at first. This seemed to fit neatly in the subgenre category called “slice-of-life.” Oh, was I wrong! Before long I found myself up at night, chewing my fingernails as the tension rose. I thought I had the villain’s identity all figured out, but the ending delivered a surprising and intriguing conclusion. Astfalk knows how to address evil without devolving into graphic or macabre descriptions. In some ways, this made the tension of the story even more effective than in many horror or thriller novels I have read, giving me a newfound respect for the romance genre as a whole.

My warning to readers, if there is any, would be that the pace goes slowly. This is not a book to reach for when you want escapism. This is a book to remind yourself that there is both light and darkness in the world, and the light will win all in good time.

Join Here for FREE to Never Miss a Deal

Find new favorites & Support Catholic Authors

Everything Old: Love in Anadauk Book 1 by Amanda Hamm

Two youth group leaders rekindle their friendship and find love with each other along the way.

A Life Such As Heaven Intended by Amanda Lauer

A chance encounter with an amnesiac soldier leads Brigid to discover the realities of the Civil War.

Rightfully Ours by Carolyn Asfalk

When Paul & Rachel discover a hidden treasure they wrestle with the responsibility of it– even as they face similar questions in their relationship.

Demons are Forever by Declan Finn

Marco flees from his fears of hurting Amanda by taking a job to train Vampire Hunters in San Francisco. Should be a quiet job right?

August & September New Book Releases

Step into Fall with a Good Book

Falling Into Place by Susan Brinkmann

She’s New Age; he’s Catholic—can their romance survive? And can she survive their investigation into their city’s Satanic hate crimes?

Anno Domini 2064 by Jacob Clearfield

Mark is happy serving the Party of the Golden Republic, but when he discovers God, he risks losing everything.

Why Reading Fiction Made Me a Better Catholic

How reading fiction became a crucial step in my conversion to the Catholic Church.

Summer at West Castle By Theresa Linden

Is God really leading Caitlyn to bad boy Jarret?

Editor’s Choice Awards 2026

Every year our staff picks out our favorite books that we've read that year. We don't rank them and categorize them only by genre, because, like with all art, this is list is purely subjective and your personal tastes and spiritual needs should be foremost when...

Messina: Book 1, The Casa Bella Chronicles By Liz Galvano

Romance blossoms in the midst of chaos. A historical romance set in 1901 Italy as a young American doctor proves herself to the haughty Italian lord who has forgotten his faith.

Anyone But Him by Theresa Linden

What if you woke up one day and didn’t recognize the person you were sleeping next to?

I Hope You Find Joy By Eliza Mae Albano

Can Emma find joy with the man who hurt her?

Gifts Visible and Invisible

If you are looking for a cozy read to get into the Christmas cheer, this collection has it all.

Best Books of 2022

Our favorite book finds of the year!

2026 Readers Choice Award Winners

2026 Catholic Readers Choice Award Winners for best Catholic books of the year. Fiction and Nonfiction!

Playing by Heart by Carmela Martino

In this historical drama, Emilia longs for a love as beautiful as her sonata, but the ambitions of her father put her and her sister in great danger. Winner of our 2018 Best of the Year Awards.

Where to Begin with C.S. Lewis

When he was four years old, C. S. Lewis renamed himself Jack and refused to answer to Clive Staples. For the rest of his life, he was Jack to his friends.

Where to Begin with Flannery O’Connor

Flannery O’Connor dissected the Devil for a generation that was busy explaining evil away. She perceived God at work in grotesque places. Was she right?

The Iron Door: Book 3, The Casa Bella Chronicles By Liz Calvano

In 1940s Sicily, will four young adults survive the war and find love? Two American women are rescued by an Italian family after their plane goes down in Sicily.