Transgender Ideology & Gender Dysphoria: A Catholic response by Dr. Jake Thibault

by | Sep 1, 2022 | Non-Fiction

Genre

Nonfiction

Audience

Adult

Author’s Worldview

Catholic

Year Published

2021

Themes

transgenderism, ideology, gender dysphoria, science, nature, nurture, virtue, history of transgender, transsexualism, summa theologica, moral theology, philosophical theology, pathology, pathogenesis

 

Reviewed by

Dr. Lisa Theus

If you have ever had a question about the transgender phenomenon, look no further than Dr. Jake Thibault’s thorough discussion in Transgender Ideology & Gender Dysphoria: A Catholic response. Throughout the book, Thibault views the issue from different angles, exploring how different groups define what have become controversial terms—gender, sex, man, woman, male, female. Even the word “transgender” can mean radically different things. Grounded in Catholic reasoning, Thibault lays out the competing views on the nature of transgenderism.  Ultimately, he offers a pastoral approach for Christians to take based upon virtue and St. Thomas Aquinas’ theology.

The book has 11 chapters: an introduction to his method; a gender framework; the relationship between the Church and culture; an overview of sexual abnormalities; three chapters on the history of transgender science; a discussion of neurodevelopment and transgenderism; the experiences of dysphoric youth; and two chapters on how to respond medically and pastorally. It is an ambitious book, to say the least. 

Bearing in mind that this book can be difficult to read, I strongly recommend it. Most of it is surprisingly engaging. Thibault also helps the reader by including an introduction and conclusion to every chapter. If you have a background in philosophy or enjoy more academic works, such as the publications by Word on Fire, you’ll enjoy this. And if you’re willing to take on something that might be outside your reading comfort zone, I think you’ll also be very satisfied. I found I looked forward to reading it more than some fiction because the content was so fascinating. 

I consider it a must-read for anyone who wants to approach discussions of transgenderism with both reason and faith. The perspective is definitely Catholic, quoting many popes as well as St. Thomas Aquinas. But any Christian will benefit from the both/and of the information within – we both have to love the people with these feelings and also uphold the truth of God’s design for humankind.

Thibault concludes with a discussion of virtue as a practical guideline for living out God’s plan for those who experience gender dysphoria. I found this section particularly rewarding because the lessons apply to everyone, no matter what crosses they bear. It also reinforces a thread of the book: all people have the same dignity, created in God’s image. It can be easy to be carried away by scandalous events and the rhetoric of some transgender activists, but that doesn’t get to the root of the real issue. Thibault is dedicated to rejecting what is logically unsound while being sympathetic to the people who experience these “other body” feelings. Christians can’t save others through hate.

Even secular readers will find much of interest in the chapters that focus on the scientific studies. While they might not care about the authority of the Church, the overall analysis is thought-provoking to anyone, Christian or not, who is interested in hearing different sides of the transgender debate. And as Thibault doesn’t rely on fiery rhetoric himself, people who want to discuss will find much to engage with.  There will likely be people who dismiss this work out of hand, but only those prejudiced to an extreme view. I suspect the reason Thibault included so much content is for the extreme activists so that he couldn’t be accused of omission.

I will repeat the caveat that parts of this book can be challenging to read. It feels to me more like a dissertation than a book intended for a general audience—it is well researched, but at times dense with academic jargon. It also seems like the final editing may have been rushed, as occasional typos only add to the reading difficulty, at least in the version I had at time of review. The book is already daunting for many readers at over 600 pages, so some may prefer to get a ‘Cliff Notes’ summary. Perhaps we’ll be lucky and receive a shorter, clearer version in the future for pastoral small groups.

But given the urgency of the issue and the need for a Catholic response, I have and will continue to recommend this book to any reader serious about thinking about transgenderism. It is well worth the more challenging passages, and those who enjoy intellectual engagement will not be disappointed.

Get Catholic Books & eBooks for as little as $1 to FREE

Bead by Bead: The Scriptural Rosary by Meggie K. Daly 

A scriptural meditation and a moving witness of how the rosary brought the author back to The Church.

Ascend to Your Father by John Hammes ph.d

This book brings us to a unity with the Triune God who loves us so much that he sent his Son to redeem the world and sanctify us through the Holy Spirit.

Broken Brain; Fortified Faith: Lessons of Hope Through a Child’s Mental Illness

When her daughter is stricken insane her mother finds the grace to do what she must to save her and bring her back to sanity.

Broken and Blessed: An Invitation to My Generation By Fr. Josh Johnson

Fr. Josh addresses some of the common misconceptions people have about God and what getting to actually know him actually means.

Five Things with Father Bill by William Byrne

Humorous and Pithy, Fr. Bill has 5 tips for any season of life

Finding God Anew by Barbara Kudwa

After multiple divorces, a suicide, and a murder, Barbara Kudwa shares how she found peace through her faith in God.

Help from Heaven by Andrea Jo Rodgers

In this year of tragedy, Rodgers reminds us of the miracle of human kindness.

On Heaven’s Doorstep by Andrea Jo Rodgers

When you’re on the front lines of life and death, it’s hard to avoid seeing real miracles.

Image of God, Personhood & the Embryo by Calum MacKeller

Abortion is not the only danger to the human embryo. Defend humanity from experimentation in the USA.

The Science of God: The Convergence of Scientific and Biblical Wisdom by Gerald L. Schroeder

Essential reading for anyone involved in the debate between religion and science.

Wanderings of an Ordinary Pilgrim by Tim Bete

Poetry that will take you deeper into Scripture and help you see the extraordinary in the simple.

How to Nourish Your Marriage by M.C. So

Steps to improve your marriage with the sacraments.

The Tale of Patrick Peyton

How a humble, Irish immigrant brought Mary to Hollywood and then the World.

Best of 2020

Yes some good things DID happen this year- Catholic creators have not let turmoil stop their mission.

Girl Arise by By Claire Swinarski

A Catholic take on feminism, going beyond the political talking points and approaching women on a personal level.

Paul’s Prayers by Susan Anderson

A mother reveals with honesty and authenticity the difficulties of raising a child with autism and the struggles that child faces every minute of every day.

Saving Cinderella: What Feminists Get Wrong About Disney Princesses And How To Set It Right by Faith Moore

Love the Disney movies you grew up with but don’t know how to defend them in the face of the modern critics? This book is for you.

Abolishing Abortion by Fr. Frank Pavone

An invaluable handbook for pro-life religious non-profits that want to protect life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness—without risking their tax-exempt status.