Genre

Historical Fiction, Mystery, Middle Grade

Audience

Ages 12-14

Author’s Worldview

Catholic

Year Published

2021

Themes

Pride, Disability, Vocations, Priesthood, Monks, Monasteries, English History, England, Catholic English History, Catholic England, Nuns, Vocation Discernment, Theft, Treasure, The Crusades

Reviewed by

A.R.K Watson

Xan has settled into his new life at the monastery and is trying to be a good person and leader to the other boys but troublemaker John seems set on undermining him every chance he gets. Then Xan receives a message from his Uncle, offering him an apprenticeship and future as a merchant in the city. The prospect of joining his only living family is enticing but, what if God is calling him to take vows? Then again, there is also that moment he had with Lucy when he ran into her in Lincoln. When his beloved mentor Brother Andrew asks him to come to Grenton Priory for his ordination, Xan is able to convince his Uncle to wait for his answer, but he only has until they return. While in Grenton, a priceless treasure goes missing and Xan is on the case to hunt for it. He even lets John tag along and pretends like he’s helping. But the investigation soon reveals that crime can exist even in a holy monastery and vows do not necessarily protect one from the world. This is a fun historical mystery that explores the discernment of religious life in a very relatable manner.

Aside from vocations, disability, pride, and humility are also major themes. Two of Xan’s companions in this book are physically disabled and they view their disabilities in wildly different ways. One of them was born disabled and while he wishes he could climb trees like his brother, he generally views life and his worth positively. The other is newly disabled from an accident and struggling with feelings of worthlessness. Xan and his other friends are also challenged to think critically about how they include or exclude these two boys and though Xan discounts them at first he gradually learns that making small accommodations to include the other boys is not just the morally right thing to do but that his two friends have more than a few hidden talents that Xan comes to rely on for help by the end of the story as well. I’m summarizing and simplifying here for the sake of brevity but, there is a lot in this story to make any reader, child or adult, think critically about their own tendencies to pride and small ways they might be discounting those around them, disabled or otherwise. This book challenged me and I look forward to discussing it with my son when he is old enough to read it.

Though this is the third in the series, this book can be read and understood apart from the previous two. Aside from the fact that this book takes place pre-Protestant reformation, there is nothing in this that would greatly offend a Protestant or Secular reader and thus could make for a good book through which to foster ecumenical discussion. The characters are all trying to be good people, a struggle with which nearly anyone will relate. Though I as an adult have found this series quite entertaining, these books are especially appropriate for ages seven through 14 and for introducing young readers to the Historical Fiction genre. There is a map of the area, a glossary of historical terms at the back and an explanation of the time period and some leading questions about the themes of the book that will give young readers the context they need to learn about both the Middle Ages and this type of literature. For this reason, teachers especially will not regret including this in either their required or suggested reading lists. Catholic families as well will love adding this book to the shelf. The chapters are about five pages long on average, which makes for good bite-sized reading before bed.

Shadow in the Dark was one of our Best of 2020 books and these sequels have only been increasing in talented writing and entertainment. I hope Kolenc keeps writing because this series might be the Catholic family’s next Hardy Boys or Nancy Drew.

 

Get Catholic Books & eBooks for as little as $1 to FREE

August & September New Book Releases

Step into Fall with a Good Book

Legion by William Peter Blatty

When a boy is crucified, Detective Kinderman finds himself chasing down a murderer who is already dead.

Outlaws of Ravenhurst, by Sr. M. Imelda Wallace, S.L.

The 10-year-old heir of a noble Scottish family must choose between his inheritance and his Catholic faith.

Julia’s Gifts by Ellen Gable

A story of love and God’s providence in times of war.

The Boy Who Knew (Friends in High Places: Carlo Acutis) by Corinna Turner

Faced with his death, a fifteen-year-old learns how to live through the wisdom of Blessed Carlo Acutis.

A Life Such As Heaven Intended by Amanda Lauer

A chance encounter with an amnesiac soldier leads Brigid to discover the realities of the Civil War.

Men at Arms by Evelyn Waugh

Evelyn Waugh’s great Catholic novel that is not Brideshead Revisited.

Unlikely Witnesses by Leslea Wahl

When four boys glimpse a crime in their Colorado town they end up in an interrogation cell of the FBI.

The Mission of Joan Of Arc by Philip Kosloski, Alexandre Nascimento, and Jesse Hansen

Voyage Comics’ dynamic interpretation of the Life of Joan of Arc is based on the play written by St. Thérèse of Lisieux.

Lily of the Mohawks By Philip Kosloski, Bruno Abdias, Chuck Michael Obach

Will Tekakwitha obey her uncle and marry a warrior, or boldly live out her faith?

Officers and Gentlemen by Evelyn Waugh

Evelyn Waugh’s brilliant examination of the moral fatigue of men at war.

The Fifth Gospel by Ian Caldwell

This is NOT another DaVinci Code, but it is so cleverly disguised as one it makes the perfect gift for your anti-Catholic friends and family.

Where to begin with Dorothy L. Sayers?

A Detective novelist who believes in conscience, and in the reality of redemption.

Max Medal Knight, Volume 2 By Voyage Comics

To save his mother, Max must don his knight’s armor for the first time.

Finnian and the Seven Mountains (Vol. 1) by Philip Koslowski, Michael Lavoy, and Jim Fern

Join Finnian as his quest for a legendary sword takes him to the monks of Skellig Michael, a real life inspiration for the Jedi temple.

A Distant Prospect by Annette Young

Lucy has been broken by the horrors of polio and the war for Irish Independence. Can Australia offer her a new life and a new home?

Will Wilder and the Relic of Perilous Falls

Follow Will Wilder as he discovers a hidden world, fights demons and rescues a hidden treasure!

Lance and the Veil by Kevin Rush

She was Christ’s comforter, he, his executioner. Can the two find love in each other’s arms?

Messina: Book 1, The Casa Bella Chronicles By Liz Galvano

Romance blossoms in the midst of chaos. A historical romance set in 1901 Italy as a young American doctor proves herself to the haughty Italian lord who has forgotten his faith.

The Haunted Cathedral by Antony Barone Kolenc                           

Xan is finally bringing his parent’s killer to justice, yet his guardian monk insists he must forgive the murderer